American Socialist: The Life and Legacy of Eugene V. Debs
By Shawn Gude
Simon & Schuster, 416 pages, $30
Eugene V. Debs was the founder and four-time presidential candidate of the American Socialist Party. In 1920, while in jail for opposing US entry into World War I, Debs received almost a million votes for president. That election, however, marked the last hurrah for Debs and the Socialists. The Socialist Party crumbled and ceased to be a force within American politics. Debs became, at best, a footnote in history textbooks. In 1978, Bernie Sanders, out of work and politics, began a rough-hewn documentary on his hero with the apt warning: “It is very probable, especially if you are a young person, that you have not heard of Eugene Victor Debs.”
But Debs’s name is being heard again amid a revival of American socialism for which Sanders can take considerable credit. The last biography of Debs, by the outstanding labor historian Nick Salvatore, was published forty years ago. This year, Simon & Schuster has brought out a 400-page biography by Jacobin contributor Shawn Gude, who has done his homework.
The book is noteworthy for highlighting Debs’s support for racial equality and for its portrayal of his prison years. Gude gives Debs his due for being an early supporter of industrial unions and for putting socialism on the American agenda before World War I, but he also recognizes Debs’s failings as a party leader and politician. He does justice to his subject’s courage and conviction as a public man without eliding his struggle with alcohol and his troubled marriage. I have bones to pick with some of Gude’s interpretations, but that is to be expected when addressing the question of why Debs and the party ultimately failed and what can be learned from these failures.