American Scapegoat:
How a Corrupt Justice System Sacrificed Derek Chauvin to the Mob
By T.J. Harker
Passage, 400 pages, $34.95
Derek Chauvin, the former Minneapolis police officer convicted of murdering George Floyd in 2020, was stabbed twenty-two times while in federal custody. Though he survived, he has become America’s scapegoat—the title of T.J. Harker’s meticulous new book on the Chauvin trial. Harker, a former assistant US attorney, has prosecuted many such cases. Drawing on his experience, he shows where the conventional narrative goes wrong.
As a strict legal matter, Chauvin’s case is not about race relations, patterns of police conduct, or any of the other controversies for which it was taken as evidence. It is about whether Chauvin, in fact, committed a crime and received a fair trial. In the American system, justice requires clear, rebuttable charges brought before a neutral magistrate and an impartial jury that decides on the basis of clear evidence, not hysteria or fear. The prosecution must charge only what the evidence can bear, while giving the accused fair notice of how the evidence will be organized. Exculpating evidence or material that would impeach the state’s own witnesses must also be given to the defense.
In the mob-like atmosphere that surrounds high-profile and politically charged cases, these safeguards come under assault. Prosecutors playing to the crowd can act unethically. Judges can bow to the mob too. No number of peremptory challenges will change the fact that jury pools can hate the accused, refuse to listen at trial, bow to the crowd, and preordain a conviction.